01
Best overall pick
Pizza Booyah
Downtown Willoughby • Craft Pizza Bar • Local Favorite For Creative Pies
A polished, modern spot turning out inventive pizzas with a neighborhood-bar feel.
Pizza Booyah is the kind of place locals name first when friends ask where to meet for pizza in Willoughby. The menu leans into thoughtful toppings and well-balanced flavor combos, so you can go classic or get a little adventurous without missing the mark. It’s a comfortable choice for dinner before drinks on Erie Street or a relaxed night out with friends.
02
Old-school standby
Best Pizza & Sandwiches
Vine Street Corridor • Classic Takeout Pizzeria • Best For Value And Big Portions
A no-frills shop loved for generously topped pies, subs, and dependable takeout.
Best Pizza & Sandwiches feels like the neighborhood joint that’s been feeding teams, busy families, and night-shift crews for years. The crust is sturdy, the cheese is plentiful, and the toppings come piled on, making it a strong value play. It’s the spot you call when you want solid, familiar pizza without overthinking it.
03
Chain with a twist
Jet's Pizza
Euclid Avenue Strip • Detroit-Style Chain Pizzeria • Best For Thick-Crust Comfort
A go-to for square, cheesy, edge-to-edge Detroit-style pies with serious crunch.
Jet’s brings its signature Detroit-style pizza to Willoughby with thick, airy crusts and caramelized edges that make the corners highly contested territory. The menu is built for customization, from flavored crusts to hearty topping combinations. It’s especially appealing on cold nights when you want something rich, cheesy, and seriously filling.
04
Hidden-gem pick
Big Cheese Pizza
East End Willoughby • Neighborhood Pizzeria • Best For Low-Key Takeout Night
A small, straightforward shop turning out comforting, classic pizzas for carryout and delivery.
Big Cheese Pizza doesn’t chase trends; it focuses on the kind of familiar pies that taste like a Friday night in. The menu sticks to the basics, but they do those basics well, from balanced sauce to reliably melty cheese. It’s a solid option when you want an easy, unfussy pizza fix close to home.
05
Reliable chain choice
Marco's Pizza
Som Center Corridor • Carryout And Delivery Chain • Most Reliable For Quick Delivery
A widely known chain that delivers consistent, customizable pizzas with plenty of combo deals.
Marco’s is a familiar name, but that’s part of the appeal when you just need dinner handled. The crust, sauce, and toppings are consistent from one order to the next, and there are usually coupons or bundles that keep the total reasonable. It’s the dependable backup plan for busy weeknights or game-day spreads when timing matters as much as taste.