01
Best overall pick
Pizza Booyah
Near Historic Downtown Willoughby • Creative Craft‑Pizza Shop • Best For Inventive Pies
Inventive toppings, a chewy, blistered crust, and a laid‑back vibe make Pizza Booyah the place to go when you want more than a basic cheese pie.
Pizza Booyah leans into bold flavors, with specialty pies that layer things like spicy meats, roasted veggies, and drizzle sauces over a well‑seasoned crust. The menu is compact but focused, so even the classic pepperoni gets extra care in the bake and the balance of cheese to sauce. It is a strong choice when you are meeting friends and want something that feels local and a bit different without being fussy.
02
Best value spot
Best Pizza & Sandwiches
Vine Street Strip In Willoughby • Old‑School Takeout Joint • Budget‑Friendly Local Favorite
This no‑nonsense counter joint turns out generously topped pizzas and big subs at prices that work for weeknight takeout.
Best Pizza & Sandwiches is the kind of unfussy neighborhood place locals rely on when nobody wants to cook. The pizza skews classic American: sturdy crust, plenty of cheese, and a toppings list that covers all the usual suspects plus a few hearty specialty combinations. Add in wings, fries, and subs, and it is especially handy for feeding a hungry group without overthinking the order.
03
Best for Detroit‑style
Jet's Pizza
Euclid Avenue Corridor In Willoughby • Detroit‑Style Chain Pizzeria • Reliable Crowd‑Pleaser
Square, thick‑crust Detroit‑style pies with caramelized cheese edges and customizable flavored crusts make this Jet's location a dependable go‑to.
If you are craving that airy‑yet‑hefty pan crust, Jet's in Willoughby delivers the signature Detroit‑style experience with crisp corners and plenty of cheese. The menu lets you play around with crust flavors, sauces, and topping combos, so it is easy to dial in something that works for picky eaters and adventurous friends alike. It is particularly good for game nights or parties when you want pizzas that feel substantial and travel well.
04
Best hometown delivery
Gionino's Pizzeria
Som Center Road In Willoughby Hills • Neighborhood Delivery Staple • Go‑To Delivery Option
A regional favorite for sweet‑leaning sauce, edge‑to‑edge toppings, and reliable delivery, Gionino's is a natural first call from Willoughby Hills.
Gionino's Pizzeria is a familiar name around Northeast Ohio, and the Willoughby Hills shop keeps to the formula that made it popular. Pizzas come with lightly sweet red sauce, plenty of cheese, and toppings scattered generously all the way to the crust. With fried chicken, jojo potatoes, and other comfort sides on the same menu, it is ideal when you want a full spread dropped right at your door.
05
Best sit‑down experience
Mama Roberto's
Mentor Retail Corridor • Classic Red‑Sauce Italian Restaurant • Best For Families
Hearty pizzas, big pastas, and a warm, old‑school dining room make Mama Roberto's worth the short drive from Willoughby Hills.
Mama Roberto's feels like a traditional family Italian spot, with cozy booths, generous portions, and pizzas that arrive bubbling hot from the oven. The crust sits in that sweet spot between soft and crisp, sturdy enough to handle piles of cheese and toppings without turning heavy. It is an easy recommendation for family dinners, birthdays, or any night when you want pizza plus the option of garlic bread, pasta, and a lingering meal at the table.