Wilson sits in the rolling hills between Monroe and Belmont counties, where pizza nights usually mean a scenic drive to a nearby river town or interstate exit. The local scene leans heavily on Ohio Valley–style pies: square-cut, cheese baked right to the edge, and best eaten straight from the box. From Shadyside to St. Clairsville, these spots are the ones locals recommend when you ask where to go for a solid pizza run.
A small, no-frills shop serving the quintessential square-cut Ohio Valley pizza that locals will happily drive for.
Shadyside’s DiCarlo's is a favorite for that classic tray-style Ohio Valley pie piled with fresh cheese as soon as it comes out of the oven. It’s mostly a grab-and-go operation, so plan to pick up a few trays and head back toward Wilson or down to the riverfront to eat.
A busy outpost of the Ohio Valley staple, known for crispy crust, edge-to-edge cheese, and a steady stream of regulars.
This St. Clairsville DiCarlo's feels like a weekly ritual for many Belmont County families, and it’s one of the most reliable stops if you’re already up by the mall or interstate. From Wilson, it’s a bit of a drive, but the hot trays, cold sodas, and familiar flavors make it an easy choice when you’re feeding a crowd.
A long-running Bellaire carryout spot turning out classic DiCarlo's squares that travel well back toward Wilson.
If your pizza run takes you along the river, the Bellaire DiCarlo's is an easy detour for a box or two of their signature squares. Service is brisk, the menu is straightforward, and it’s the kind of place where calling in an order before you leave Wilson pays off in hot pizza ready at pickup.
A flexible option with everything from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty pies, stromboli, and wings for mixed groups.
Vocelli in St. Clairsville works well when not everyone in the group wants the same thing, thanks to their long list of toppings and specialty combinations. It’s easy to reach from the interstate, and the mix of pizzas, sides, and salads makes it a sensible stop on the way back to Wilson after a day of running errands.
A dependable option when you need something hot, fast, and customizable on a late drive back toward Wilson.
When other kitchens start closing, the St. Clairsville Domino's tends to still be turning out pies, making it useful for late-night or game-day cravings. The online ordering and build-your-own options are straightforward, and the consistency is a plus if you’re grabbing pizza on the way home and don’t want any surprises.