Windham may be a small Portage County village, but it sits within easy reach of some very solid pizza. From long-running carryout counters in town to family pizzerias in nearby Garrettsville and Ravenna, you can find everything from classic pepperoni pies to loaded specialty combinations. Use this list as a starting point for your next casual night out or low-key takeout run.
Long-running Windham shop turning out reliable, crowd-pleasing pies with generous toppings.
Locals lean on Stoney's for everything from Friday night dinners to team parties and family gatherings. The menu keeps to the classics—think cheese, pepperoni, and simple specialty combos—done in a familiar, no-fuss style. Call ahead on busy evenings; the ovens stay busy when the village is craving pizza.
Straightforward pies, big slices, and easy takeout right off the main drag in Garrettsville.
Cal's is the kind of place where you can pop in for a slice at lunch or grab a couple of hot boxes on your way home. Crust runs on the classic hand-tossed side, with plenty of cheese and familiar toppings that please a mixed crowd. It is especially handy if you are already in Garrettsville for errands or a game.
Broad menu of pizzas, wings, and subs that makes large group ordering simple.
Zeppe's gives you the consistency of a regional chain with the ease of pickup close to Windham. The menu runs from classic round pies to sheet pizzas, plus wings, salads, and sides, so everyone can find something. It is a smart call for birthday parties, team celebrations, or any night when you are ordering for a big group.
Old-school Ravenna favorite with hearty pies and a comfortable, low-key dining room.
Caporaletti's draws regulars with its familiar red-sauce comfort and straightforward, generously topped pizzas. The atmosphere is unpretentious and welcoming, making it an easy place to bring kids, grandparents, or out-of-town friends. If you want to sit down, chat, and linger over a pie rather than rush home with a box, this is a good bet.
Craveable pizza, fried chicken, and jojo potatoes that turn a simple order into a full spread.
Gionino's is a Northeast Ohio staple, and the Ravenna location is a handy option when you want more than just a pie. The pizza leans hearty and cheesy, and many regulars add on wings or fried chicken to round out the meal. It is a strong choice for game days or any night when you are feeding a hungry crowd at home.