01
Best overall pick
Whitmer's Pizza
In The Heart Of Winesburg • Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Local Staple
Your closest, classic option for a hot pie right in Winesburg.
Formerly known as Winesburg Pizza, Whitmer's is the spot locals rely on when they want something easy and satisfying without leaving town. The menu leans into familiar favorites: generous cheese, plenty of toppings, and hearty crusts built for takeout. It is the place you call after a ballgame or when you are settling into a nearby inn and want a low-fuss pizza night.
02
Worth the drive
Park Street Pizza
Downtown Sugarcreek • Farm-To-Table Pizza And Wings Spot • Destination Pizza
A polished small-town shop known for quality toppings and a buzzy, casual feel.
About a short drive northeast of Winesburg, Park Street Pizza has built a regional following for pies topped with fresh, often locally sourced ingredients. The menu runs from simple pepperoni to loaded specialty combinations, plus wings and salads that feel a cut above standard takeout fare. Go early on weekends if you want to avoid a wait, and plan to sit and linger rather than just grab and go.
03
Best for families
East of Chicago Pizza Millersburg
Millersburg Shopping Corridor • Casual Buffet-Style Chain Pizzeria • Crowd-Pleasing Choice
A flexible option where everyone can find something they like, from pan pizza to dessert slices.
Down in Millersburg, this East of Chicago location is popular with families and groups thanks to its build-your-own and buffet-style setup. Thick, cheesy pan pizzas share space with thin-crust options, pasta, and a few indulgent dessert pizzas. It is a practical stop when you have hungry kids in tow or need to feed a group after a long day of exploring back roads.
04
Most convenient near Berlin
East of Chicago Pizza Berlin
Berlin Tourist Strip • Takeout-Focused Chain Shop • Easy Grab-And-Go
A straightforward choice for fast, customizable pies right off Berlin’s main drag.
Berlin is one of the busiest hubs in Amish Country, and this East of Chicago location is set up for quick orders between shops and attractions. Expect all the chain standards, from build-your-own pizzas to subs and wings, with plenty of topping combinations that travel well back to your cabin or motel. It is not fussy, but it is reliable when time is tight and you just need a solid pizza in the car within minutes.
05
Classic dine-in chain
Pizza Hut Millersburg
East Millersburg • National Chain Dine-In And Carryout • Reliable Standby
Familiar pan pizza and breadsticks in a laid-back, family-friendly setting.
For visitors who like to know exactly what they are getting, the Pizza Hut on the edge of Millersburg offers the same menu you see across the country. The draw here is the combination of dine-in booths and easy carryout, making it a simple option on busy summer evenings. It is a good backup when smaller spots are packed or closed and you still want a hot, consistent pie within a short drive of Winesburg.