01
Best grab-and-go slices
Lucy Blue Pizza
Clough Pike In Anderson Township • Laid-Back Slice Counter • Go-To For Quick Bites
A casual east-side staple serving foldable slices and whole pies with a friendly, no-frills vibe.
Lucy Blue’s Anderson outpost is one of the closest true pizzerias to Withamsville, ideal when you want pizza without driving into the city. The menu skews classic—think pepperoni, veggie, and meat-heavy combos—but the slices are generous and travel well. It’s a convenient choice for takeout on busy weeknights or an easy stop after errands along Clough Pike.
02
Best casual hangout
Cincinnati Goodfellows
Near Anderson Town Center • Italian-Inspired Pizzeria And Bar • Best For Groups And Game Nights
A neighborhood spot where crisp pizzas share the spotlight with a full bar and plenty of TVs.
Goodfellows feels like a classic local hangout, with pizza that pairs well with a cold beer and a Reds game on in the background. The crust leans crisp and sturdy, built to handle hearty toppings without getting soggy. It works especially well for meeting friends from both Withamsville and Anderson, since it sits an easy hop off Beechmont Avenue.
03
Best for families
Dewey's Pizza
Anderson Towne Center • Lively Family-Friendly Pizzeria • Family Favorite
A polished yet welcoming spot known for creative specialty pies and an open kitchen that keeps kids entertained.
Dewey’s Anderson draws east-side families for its reliable service and playful topping combinations, from classic pepperoni to pies loaded with veggies and goat cheese. The crust hits a balance between chewy and crisp, and half-and-half pizzas make it easy to keep everyone at the table happy. It’s a smart pick when you want something a step up from delivery without feeling overly formal.
04
Destination Neapolitan pie
Joe's Pizza Napoli
Near I-275 In Milford • Neapolitan Wood-Fired Pizzeria • Worth-The-Drive Pick
A serious pizza shop turning out blistered, wood-fired Neapolitan pies that attract fans from across the east side.
Joe’s is the place to go when you’re in the mood for soft, leopard-spotted crust and restrained, high-quality toppings. Pizzas arrive with a tender center and puffed edges, built for eating knife-and-fork or folded over like a true Neapolitan. From simple margherita to richer options with cured meats, it feels more like a destination restaurant than a quick slice stop, but it’s still close enough to be a realistic Withamsville weeknight treat.
05
Best historic-downtown vibe
Padrino
Downtown Milford • Brick-Oven Italian Restaurant • Date-Night Friendly
A cozy spot on Milford’s main drag serving well-made pizzas alongside pastas and Italian comfort food.
Set in the heart of old Milford, Padrino offers a warm, brick-walled backdrop that makes pizza feel a bit more special. The pies lean classic American-Italian, with a sturdy crust, plenty of cheese, and toppings that range from simple sausage to more loaded house combinations. It’s a good choice when one person wants pizza, another wants pasta, and everyone wants to pair it with a drink and a stroll through downtown.