01
Best overall pick
Michael's Pizza
Downtown Urbana • Classic Hometown Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Sit-Down Pies
A long-running Urbana staple known for generous, square-cut pies and a laid-back small-town vibe.
If you ask around Woodstock where people go for a classic pizza night, Michael's in downtown Urbana comes up fast. The crust lands in that sweet spot between chewy and crisp, with plenty of toppings and a sauce that leans savory instead of sweet. It is an easy choice when you want a relaxed dine-in meal after a short drive into town.
02
Best thin-crust stop
Donatos Pizza
Urbana East Side • Thin-Crust Chain Pizzeria • Best For Crispy, Edge-To-Edge Toppings
A reliable spot for Columbus-style thin crust with toppings spread right to the edge and quick service.
For those who like their pizza thin, crispy, and neatly cut into squares, the Urbana Donatos is a convenient go-to. It works especially well for weeknights when you want to order ahead, swing through on the east side, and head back toward Woodstock without lingering. The menu is broad enough that everyone in the car can find something, from classic pepperoni to lighter veggie pies.
03
Best for easy delivery
Marco's Pizza
Urbana Us-36 Corridor • Carryout And Delivery Pizza Shop • Best For Custom Orders And Combos
A handy choice for build-your-own pizzas, cheesy bread, and meal deals that travel well back to the village.
Marco's in Urbana is popular with families who want to customize everything, from crust and sauce to toppings and sides. It is especially useful when you are feeding a crowd and need dependable delivery or a quick carryout stop along US-36. The robust sauce, chewy crust, and frequent specials make it a solid value for a pizza night at home in Woodstock.
04
Best for big groups
Benny's Pizza
Marysville East Side • Lively Family Roadhouse • Best For Patio Hangs And Live Music
A destination-style pizza spot with roomy dining, a busy patio in season, and plenty of crowd-pleasing pies.
When you want more than just a quick slice, Benny's in Marysville turns pizza into a full evening out. Locals make the drive for its big, shareable pies, wings, and a bustling atmosphere that often includes live music and patio seating in good weather. It is a smart pick for birthdays, team outings, or any night when half of Woodstock seems to be piling into cars together.
05
Best sports-bar pizza
Boston's Restaurant & Sports Bar
Marysville Retail District • Gourmet Pizza And Sports Bar • Best For Game-Day Gatherings
A polished sports bar with a surprisingly deep pizza menu, from classic pepperoni to more creative specialty pies.
If you are chasing both good pizza and a wall of TV screens, Boston's in Marysville fits the bill. The crust runs a bit more upscale than standard bar pizza, and the specialty options let you branch out beyond the usual toppings. It is the kind of place Woodstock residents head to when there is a big game on and they want to settle in with a pint and a shareable pie.