01
Old-school institution
Coccia House
Near Downtown Wooster • Sit-Down Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria • Best Overall Pick
A Wooster landmark known for hefty, pan-style pies and a no-frills, hometown feel.
Coccia House has been the default answer to “Where should we get pizza?” in Wooster for decades, and the recipe hasn’t changed much. Expect thick, bready crusts, generous cheese, and toppings piled on in classic Ohio tavern-pizza fashion. Go with a group, split a large specialty pie, and plan on leftovers for the next day.
02
Carryout classic
Gionino's Pizzeria
Downtown Wooster • Casual Carryout And Delivery Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups
Reliable, shareable pizzas and famous fried chicken make this a go-to takeout spot.
Just off the main downtown streets, Gionino’s is where locals turn when they need to feed a crowd without overthinking it. The crust is sturdy enough for heavy toppings, and the sweet-leaning red sauce is classic northeast Ohio. Pair a couple of sheet pizzas with their JoJo potatoes and chicken and you’ve got an easy game-day or party spread.
03
Creative slice
Romeo's Pizza
North End Of Wooster • Chain Pizzeria With Creative Specialty Pies • Best For Specialty Toppings
A regional chain known for sweet-leaning sauce, thick-cut pepperoni, and loaded specialty pizzas.
Romeo’s leans into bold flavors, with menu favorites like barbecue chicken, white garlic pies, and loaded meat combinations. The crust is a touch thicker and chewier than most delivery chains, which holds up well for heavier builds. It’s an easy pick when you want something more interesting than a standard pepperoni without straying too far from comfort food territory.
04
Polished night out
Mariola Italian
Downtown Dining District • Modern Italian Bistro With Artisan Pizza • Best For Date Night
Handcrafted pies, house-made pasta, and a thoughtful wine list in a stylish downtown setting.
Part of the Mike Mariola restaurant group, this spot treats pizza with the same care it gives its pastas and small plates. Crusts are thinner and more fired than your typical delivery pie, with balanced toppings and seasonal ingredients popping up on specials. It’s the place to linger over a margherita or prosciutto-topped pie with a glass of red rather than rush in and out with a box.
05
Neighborhood standby
Bosco's Pizza Kitchen
East Side Of Wooster • Family-Friendly Pizza And Pasta Spot • Best For Families
Casual booths, kid-friendly pies, and straightforward Italian-American comfort food.
Bosco’s keeps things simple and approachable, with medium-thick crusts, familiar toppings, and plenty of cheese. It’s the kind of place where youth teams pile in after a game and regulars are on a first-name basis with the staff. Grab a large pepperoni, some breadsticks, and a pasta dish or two and everyone at the table will find something to be happy about.