01
Best for craft beer and pizza
Pies & Pints
Worthington Place / North High Street • Craft Beer Pizza Bar • Best For Craft Beer And Creative Toppings
Inventive pizzas, a deep craft beer list, and a lively patio make Pies & Pints a go-to for groups and after-work meetups.
Pies & Pints leans into bold topping combos, from spicy pepperoni with pickled jalapeños to veggie-forward pies that still feel indulgent. The rotating craft beer lineup and good-sized bar mean you can treat it as much as a taproom as a pizzeria. It’s an easy pick when you need a place that works for friends, coworkers, and families all at once.
02
Best for families
Dewey's Pizza
Downtown Worthington • Family-Friendly Specialty Pizzeria • Best For Families And Pizza Purists
Dewey’s balances creative specialty pies with approachable classics in a bright, family-friendly dining room right on High Street.
Here, you’ll find meticulously made pizzas with chewy, airy crusts and toppings that skew just adventurous enough for most tables. Kids can press up against the glass to watch dough spinning in the open kitchen, while adults sip a beer or glass of wine. It’s the kind of spot that works equally well for a weeknight dinner or a casual birthday gathering.
03
Best New York-style pies
Borgata Pizza Café
West Dublin-Granville Corridor • New York-Style Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Ny-Style Pies
Borgata dishes out foldable New York-style slices and big, shareable pies with a cozy neighborhood feel.
The crust here hits that New York-style sweet spot: thin, with just enough chew to handle generous toppings. You can build your own or lean into house specialties, then round things out with pasta or a simple salad if you’re feeding a group. With its relaxed dining room and steady takeout business, Borgata works whether you want to linger or grab a box and go.
04
Best value pick
Pizza Primo
Old Worthington / High Street • Classic Neighborhood Pizza & Sub Shop • Best Value For Casual Takeout
Pizza Primo is a longstanding local joint known for friendly service, solid pies, and generous portions at fair prices.
This is the kind of spot locals keep on speed dial for Friday nights and game days. Expect well-topped pizzas with a classic Midwest feel, plus wings, subs, and salads that make ordering for a crowd straightforward. The focus is on hearty, dependable comfort food rather than dining-room frills, which is exactly what many regulars are after.
05
Best for quick carryout
Jet's Pizza
South High Street Near Worthington Border • Carryout And Delivery Chain Pizzeria • Fast Takeout And Delivery Pick
Jet’s is the neighborhood stop for thick, crispy-edged Detroit-style squares and quick, reliable delivery.
If you’re craving a buttery, pan-baked crust with caramelized cheese around the edges, Jet’s delivers that specific fix. The menu covers everything from customizable square pies to subs and wings, so it’s easy to satisfy mixed preferences without overthinking it. With its emphasis on speed and consistency, this location is especially handy on busy weeknights.