01
Coziest neighborhood classic
Gabby's Cafe
Wyoming Avenue Business District • Family Italian Café And Pizzeria • Cozy Neighborhood Staple
A longtime Wyoming favorite pairing comforting Italian dishes with reliable, crowd-pleasing pizzas.
Gabby's feels like the kind of place where your server might remember your usual order, and the pizza fits that same comforting mold. Hand-tossed pies come with a straightforward list of toppings, from classic pepperoni to veggie-heavy combos, all on a crust that strikes a nice balance between chewy and crisp. It is an easy choice for a relaxed sit-down meal when you want pizza plus a full Italian menu at the table.
02
Best bar-and-pizza combo
Tela Bar + Kitchen
Wyoming Avenue Restaurant Row • Lively Gastropub With Creative Pies • Best For Craft Beer And Pizza
A buzzy spot where inventive pizzas share the stage with a strong beer list and modern pub menu.
Tela packs plenty of energy into its dining room and bar, and the pizzas match that vibe with bold toppings and shareable sizes. Expect cheffy touches like house-made sausage, drizzle-worthy sauces, and seasonal combinations that go well with whatever is on tap. It is the go-to choice in Wyoming when you want pizza to be part of a night out rather than just a quick bite.
03
Best for date night
Twelve08
Springfield Pike Corridor • Modern Bar And Kitchen With Wood-Fired Pizza • Date-Night Pick
A polished neighborhood hangout known for crisp, shareable pizzas and a grown-up atmosphere.
Twelve08 leans into a more modern, bar-forward feel, with pizzas that arrive blistered at the edges and generously topped. The menu tends to highlight a few well-chosen combinations rather than a long list, making ordering easy for couples and small groups. Grab a cocktail, split a couple of pies, and you have an effortless date night without leaving the neighborhood.
04
Most reliable crowd-pleaser
Dewey's Pizza (Kenwood)
Near Kenwood Towne Centre • Popular Regional Pizza Chain • Best For Families And Groups
A short drive from Wyoming, Dewey's delivers big flavors, friendly service, and plenty of room for larger parties.
Dewey's is the kind of place where everyone in the group can find a favorite, thanks to a mix of classic and offbeat specialty pies. The crust is sturdy enough for generous toppings, and you can easily do half-and-half pizzas to keep the peace at the table. With an open-kitchen feel and steady buzz, it is a dependable pick before shopping runs or after kids' activities nearby.
05
Old-school favorite
Italianette Pizza
North College Hill / West Galbraith Road • Classic Cincinnati-Style Pizzeria • Carryout Classic
A no-frills spot turning out nostalgic, sauce-forward pies that many locals grew up on.
Italianette is worth the quick drive down Galbraith when you are in the mood for straightforward, old-school pizza. Expect a thinner, party-cut style crust with a tangy red sauce and piles of cheese, plus hearty toppings like sausage and mushrooms. It is best approached as a takeout operation: call in an order, swing by on your way home to Wyoming, and you will understand why so many families keep it in their weekly rotation.