01
Best overall pick
Cousin Vinny’s Pizza
Near Downtown Xenia • Late‑Night Slice Shop And Delivery Joint • Local Favorite
Big, foldable slices and value‑focused specials make Cousin Vinny’s a go‑to for hungry Xenia locals.
Cousin Vinny’s is the place Xenia residents call when they want a hot pizza fast without overthinking it. The pies are classic Midwest style with plenty of cheese, straightforward toppings, and frequent combo deals that work well for game nights or casual get‑togethers. It’s not fancy, but it’s consistent, affordable, and reliably hits the spot after a long day.
02
Dayton-area classic
Cassano’s Pizza King
Progress Drive, Xenia • Thin‑Crust Dayton‑Style Pizzeria • Old‑School Favorite
Cassano’s serves thin, cracker‑crust pies cut into small squares, a signature Dayton‑area style that longtime locals swear by.
If you want a true regional experience, Cassano’s is the Xenia stop to make. The crust is notably thin and crisp, the toppings go almost to the edge, and the familiar square cut makes it easy to share with a crowd. It’s a family‑friendly spot where many locals grew up grabbing pies after games and school events, and it still feels like a neighborhood standby.
03
Most reliable chain option
Donatos Pizza
West Main Street Strip, Xenia • Edge‑To‑Edge Topping Chain Pizzeria • Best For Families
Donatos offers consistently crisp thin crust, edge‑to‑edge toppings, and plenty of crowd‑pleasing specialty pies.
For groups with mixed tastes, Donatos is an easy pick in Xenia. The pizzas lean thin and crunchy, and the generous spread of toppings means every bite gets some flavor. With predictable quality, build‑your‑own options, and familiar sides like wings and salads, it works well for family dinners, team celebrations, or anyone who likes a thinner crust without giving up hearty toppings.
04
Worth‑the‑drive pick
Troni Brothers Pizza
Beavercreek, Northwest Of Xenia • Casual Italian Pizzeria And Pasta Spot • Destination Pie
Troni Brothers in nearby Beavercreek dishes out hearty, Italian‑style pies with a homemade feel that justifies the short drive from Xenia.
If you’re willing to hop in the car for 15 minutes, Troni Brothers is one of the more talked‑about pizza options in the area. The crust has a satisfying chew, the sauce leans flavorful instead of overly sweet, and you can round out a meal with pastas, subs, or a simple salad. It feels more like a small Italian restaurant than a basic delivery shop, making it a solid choice for a casual night out.
05
Most unique pies
Ha Ha Pizza
Downtown Yellow Springs, Northeast Of Xenia • Eclectic, Veggie‑Friendly Pizzeria • Best For A Day‑Trip Outing
Ha Ha Pizza is a Yellow Springs institution known for its creative toppings and relaxed, artsy vibe.
About a 15‑minute drive from Xenia, Ha Ha Pizza rewards the trip with chewy crusts, plenty of fresh vegetables, and combinations you won’t find at a typical chain. The laid‑back downtown Yellow Springs setting makes it easy to pair your pie with a stroll through local shops or nearby parks. It’s a great pick when you want pizza to feel like part of a fun outing rather than just another takeout order.