01
Quirkiest local classic
HaHa Pizza
Downtown Yellow Springs • Vegetarian-Friendly Pizzeria • Best For Creative Toppings
Legendary village spot known for chewy crusts, a big salad bar, and inventive veggie-forward combinations.
HaHa Pizza has been fueling hungry hikers, students, and day-trippers for decades with pies that lean fresh and customizable. Expect a mellow, slightly hippie vibe, plenty of vegetarian and vegan-friendly options, and a crust with just enough chew. It’s the place locals send visitors who want something a little different from the usual pepperoni.
02
Best overall pick
YS Pizza Company
Downtown Yellow Springs • Classic Small-Town Pizza Parlor • Local Favorite
Reliable, crowd-pleasing pies with plenty of cheese, plus wings, hoagies, and other game-night staples.
YS Pizza Company dishes out classic, saucy pizzas that satisfy both families and late-night snackers. The menu is broad enough that everyone can find something, from basic cheese slices to loaded specialty pies. It’s an easy go-to when you want familiar flavors and quick service right in the center of town.
03
Worth-the-drive red-sauce joint
Xenia Pizza & Spaghetti House
Downtown Xenia • Family-Run Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria • Best For Sit-Down Dinners
Old-school spot where you can linger over a pizza, pasta, and a basket of garlic bread.
About 15 minutes south of Yellow Springs, Xenia Pizza & Spaghetti House feels like the kind of place regulars have been visiting for generations. Pizzas come with a classic Ohio-Italian vibe: plenty of toppings, a satisfying crust, and generous cheese. It’s a comfortable choice when you want a full dinner out rather than just a quick slice.
04
Best wood-fired pies
Old Scratch Pizza Beavercreek
Beavercreek Near Fairfield Commons • Wood-Fired Craft Pizzeria And Bar • Best For Beer And Pizza
Neapolitan-style pies blistered in a wood oven, with creative toppings and a strong local beer lineup.
Old Scratch’s Beavercreek location is a go-to for folks willing to drive a bit for standout crust. The pizzas bake fast in a roaring wood oven, giving them a soft, chewy center and charred edges that pair well with everything from spicy soppressata to seasonal veggies. Communal tables and a solid selection of regional beers make it an easy spot for groups.
05
Dayton-style legend
Marion's Piazza Beavercreek
Beavercreek Near The Mall • Thin-Crust Dayton-Style Pizzeria • Great For Big Groups
Iconic area chain serving ultra-thin square-cut pies loaded with toppings in a big, casual dining room.
Marion's Piazza is a regional institution, and the Beavercreek location puts it within an easy drive of Yellow Springs. Expect cracker-thin crust, a heavy hand with toppings, and the classic square-cut style locals grew up on. With plenty of seating and fast service, it’s especially handy for birthday parties, team dinners, and family meet-ups.