01
Best overall pick
Pizza Express
Village Center In Yorkville • Carryout And Delivery Pizzeria • Local Go-To For Weeknight Pizza
Yorkville’s hometown shop for generous pies, subs, and easy takeout.
If you ask around in Yorkville itself, Pizza Express is the name you hear most for a dependable pie. The crust lands in that sweet spot between soft and sturdy, with plenty of cheese and toppings piled on. It is an easy first choice when you want something close by that tastes like a true small-town favorite rather than a big chain.
02
Classic Ohio Valley slice
DiCarlos Pizza Tiltonsville
Tiltonsville Along Oh-7 • Old-School Square-Cut Shop • Best For Ohio Valley Style
A few minutes south of Yorkville, this spot is all about iconic cold-cheese squares.
DiCarlos in Tiltonsville is a short drive that pays off if you want the Ohio Valley style people talk about. Pans of thick, airy crust come out of the oven sauced and sizzling, then get showered with cool shredded cheese right before serving. Grab a box to go and eat it while it is still warm for the full local experience.
03
Family crowd-pleaser
DeFelice Bros Pizza Shadyside
Shadyside Near The River • Family-Friendly Pizza And Pasta Spot • Best For Families
A broad menu and customizable pies make this an easy choice when everyone wants something different.
DeFelice Bros in Shadyside feels built for family dinners and team outings, with plenty of booths and a menu that goes well beyond basic cheese pizza. Their pizzas lean hearty, with a slightly thicker crust, generous toppings, and lots of cheese. Add in wings, salads, and subs and it becomes a one-stop option when you are feeding a mixed crowd.
04
Worth the bridge crossing
DiCarlos Pizza Downtown Wheeling
Downtown Wheeling • Walk-Up Slice Window • Best Quick Slice
A downtown institution serving no-frills boxes of hot crust, sauce, and cool cheese squares.
Cross the bridge to downtown Wheeling and you can hit one of the most storied names in regional pizza. The setup is simple: order at the counter, watch pans slide in and out of the oven, then get your box of square slices topped with cool cheese. It is perfect for a fast bite before a game, a riverfront event, or the drive back up the valley.
05
Sit-down Italian with strong pies
Undos Italian Restaurant St Clairsville
Near Ohio Valley Mall In St. Clairsville • Full-Service Italian Restaurant • Best For A Sit-Down Night Out
Hearty pizzas share the spotlight with pastas, salads, and classic red-sauce dishes.
When you want pizza but also a full restaurant experience, Undos in St. Clairsville is an easy upgrade. Their pizzas come on a sturdy crust with plenty of cheese, making them good for sharing alongside appetizers and big bowls of pasta. It is the kind of place locals use for family celebrations, post-shopping dinners, and lingering over a carafe of wine rather than a quick grab-and-go slice.