01
Classic local institution
Adornetto's Selected Italian
Downtown • Classic Italian Dining Room • Essential Zanesville Classic
A longtime downtown favorite known for generous cheese, sweet sauce, and a lively, old-school Italian vibe.
If you ask around Zanesville for pizza, Adornetto's is usually the first name you hear. The crust is sturdy enough to handle plenty of toppings, and the sauce leans just a bit sweet in true Ohio Valley fashion. It is a go-to for families, team dinners, and anyone wanting that nostalgic sit-down pizza night.
02
Cozy neighborhood pick
Tat's Pizzeria
West Side • Casual Neighborhood Pizzeria • Best For Laid-Back Nights
A low-key local shop turning out hearty, well-topped pies that feel tailor-made for takeout and casual evenings in.
Tat's has the feel of a true neighborhood spot, the kind of place where regulars have a standing order. The pizza is all about comfort: chewy crust, plenty of cheese, and classic topping combos done right. It is especially good when you want solid, unfussy pizza without the downtown crowds.
03
Wood-fired standout
Russo's Wood Fired Pizza
Near Downtown Riverfront • Wood-Fired Artisan Spot • Top Pick For Pizza Purists
A wood-fired specialist focusing on blistered crusts, quality ingredients, and more creative topping combinations.
Russo's leans more artisan than old-school, with a hot oven that gives the crust those charred bubbles pizza fans obsess over. Toppings skew a bit more adventurous, but you can still get a classic pepperoni that tastes notably fresher than most. It is a strong choice when you want to sit down, linger, and enjoy a craft beer with your pie.
04
Family crowd-pleaser
Pizza Cottage
North Zanesville • Family-Friendly Regional Chain • Great For Groups And Teams
A roomy, family-oriented spot with big pizzas, plenty of booths, and a menu broad enough to keep everyone happy.
Pizza Cottage is built for gatherings, from birthday parties to post-game team meals. The pizzas come out in generous sizes with a slightly thicker crust and lots of topping coverage, plus there are wings, salads, and subs to round things out. It is an easy pick when you need space, consistency, and something for every age group.
05
Convenient carryout stop
Maxwell's Pizza
Maysville Pike Corridor • Drive-Thru Carryout Shop • Fastest Weeknight Option
A quick-stop pizzeria on Maysville Pike known for drive-thru convenience, value deals, and consistently satisfying pies.
Maxwell's is ideal when you want good pizza with minimal effort, especially on busy weeknights. The drive-thru setup makes grabbing a couple of pies, wings, or subs on the way home almost too easy. Expect straightforward, crowd-pleasing flavors rather than fussy toppings, with plenty of specials that make feeding a family affordable.