01
Best overall pick
Boone Creek Pizza & Pasta
Bolivar – Just North Of Zoar • Casual Pizza-And-Pasta Restaurant • Best For Sit-Down Dinner After Sightseeing
A friendly Bolivar staple with hearty pizzas, pasta plates, and a relaxed small-town feel.
This is the kind of place many Zoar visitors end up at after a day of walking the village streets. The menu leans into familiar comforts—generous pizzas, baked pasta, and shareable appetizers—served in a straightforward, family-friendly dining room. It is an easy choice when you want a proper meal without driving far or dressing up.
02
Old-school classic
Bolivar Pizza
Bolivar Village Center • Neighborhood Pizza Shop • Local Favorite For Carryout
A no-frills local pizzeria known for solid pies, friendly service, and dependable carryout.
Bolivar Pizza feels like the classic small-town shop that knows most customers by name. The focus is on straightforward pizzas with plenty of toppings, plus wings and a few sides to round out a casual night in. It is a convenient option if you are staying in or around Zoar and want an easy pickup spot that locals actually use.
03
Italian-leaning option
Massa Mia
Bolivar Shopping Strip Near I-77 • Casual Italian Spot With Pizza • Best For Mixing Pizza With Pasta And Subs
A laid-back Italian joint where pizza shares the spotlight with pasta, subs, and classic comfort dishes.
Massa Mia suits mixed groups where not everyone is set on pizza. Alongside their pies, you will find baked pastas, subs, and other red-sauce standards, making it easy to please a crowd. Its location near the interstate also makes it a convenient stop if you are coming or going via I-77 and want something more local than a highway chain.
04
Most unexpected pizza stop
El Albatross
Bolivar Riverside Corridor • Mexican Restaurant With Pizza On The Menu • Best For Mixed Cravings And Casual Drinks
Primarily a Mexican restaurant, El Albatross also serves pizza, making it a quirky option for groups with varied tastes.
If some in your group want tacos while others are still chasing a pizza fix, El Albatross is a handy compromise. You can pair a simple pizza with chips, salsa, and other Mexican plates in one relaxed setting. It is not a dedicated pizzeria, but it works well when variety and a laid-back atmosphere matter more than obsessing over crust styles.
05
Most reliable delivery option
East of Chicago Pizza
Navarre – Short Drive Northwest Of Zoar • Chain Carryout And Delivery Pizzeria • Best For Staying In And Ordering Pizza
A familiar regional chain offering thick-crust pizzas, build-your-own combinations, and easy delivery to nearby areas.
For nights when you would rather stay put in your Zoar rental, the Navarre East of Chicago location is a practical go-to. The menu centers on customizable pizzas, plus wings, salads, and a few comfort sides, all geared toward carryout and delivery. It is less about atmosphere and more about getting a hot, reliable pie to your door with minimal fuss.