01
Best overall pick
Arthur's Restaurant
Mentone Blvd Corridor • Old-School American Roadhouse • Local Icon For Comfort Food
A classic Mentone roadhouse for big portions, strong drinks, and friendly regulars.
Arthur’s feels like the definition of a local staple, with vinyl booths, a long bar, and well-worn charm that regulars clearly love. The menu leans into hearty standards—think chicken-fried steak, burgers, country potatoes, and nightly specials that land hot and fast. It’s the kind of place where you can roll in after a day up Highway 38, grab a plate that fills the table, and trade trail stories over a cold beer.
02
Best for hearty appetites
Mill Creek Cattle Company
East Mentone Near Mill Creek • Western-Themed Bbq And Steakhouse • Road-Trip-Worthy Meat Stop
Western décor, smoke in the air, and generous platters of brisket, ribs, and steaks make this a destination for carnivores.
Mill Creek Cattle Company leans fully into the cowboy aesthetic, from the saddle decor and barnwood walls to the country soundtrack humming in the background. Plates are unapologetically big, with slow-smoked brisket, tri-tip, baby back ribs, and loaded sides that easily feed a crew. It’s a natural choice for families, post-river days, or anyone who thinks a proper dinner starts with a basket of warm rolls and ends with barbecue sauce on their sleeves.
03
Best breakfast spot
Heska's Sugar Shack
Central Mentone • Homey Breakfast And Lunch Café • Morning Favorite
A cozy, low-key café known for generous breakfasts, house-baked sweets, and neighborly service.
Heska’s Sugar Shack is where Mentone wakes up: coffee cups clinking, griddles going, and locals catching up over stacks of pancakes. The menu covers all the diner comforts—omelets, biscuits and gravy, breakfast burritos—plus pastries and sweets that justify the name. Grab a booth or a small table, settle in, and expect your coffee to be topped off before you even ask.
04
Best for groups and casual nights
The Gourmet Pizza Shoppe
Downtown Redlands • Lively Craft Pizza Restaurant • Go-To For Sharing Pies
A bustling Redlands staple with a huge lineup of creative pizzas, plenty of seating, and a relaxed, family-friendly buzz.
A short drive from Mentone, The Gourmet Pizza Shoppe in downtown Redlands rewards the effort with one of the most eclectic pizza menus in the area. Classic pepperoni shares space with playful combinations loaded with fresh veggies, specialty meats, and unexpected toppings, so groups can easily split a few adventurous pies. The atmosphere is casual and upbeat, making it just as good for a post-game team dinner as it is for a low-key night out with friends.
05
Best classic date-night spot
Tartan of Redlands
South Redlands • Classic Steak And Prime Rib Lounge • Special-Occasion Standby
An old-school supper-club setting with martinis, prime rib, and a cozy, dimly lit dining room made for lingering.
Tartan of Redlands feels transported from another era, in the best way: dark wood, tartan touches, and a bar where regulars know their order. The menu leans classic—prime rib, steaks, seafood, and sturdy sides—paired with cocktails that skew generous rather than fussy. When Mentone locals want to trade boots and hoodies for something a bit nicer, this is the reliable spot for anniversaries, celebrations, or simply a slow, well-paced dinner.