Key Colony Beach FloridaRESTAURANTS & PLACES TO EAT
Listed below are some of the best restaurants and places to eat near Key Colony Beach, Florida.
1. Key Colony Inn Restaurant & Lounge
CLASSIC ISLAND DINING
Key Colony Inn Restaurant & Lounge is an established local favorite known for its classic American and seafood dishes served in a relaxed, welcoming setting. The menu features fresh seafood such as snapper, as well as steaks, pasta, sandwiches, and rotating chef specials. With a full bar, daily happy hour, and no dress code, the restaurant offers a charming, casual Keys dining experience for both locals and visitors.
2. Havana Jack's Oceanside Restaurant and Bar
OCEANSIDE TIKI RETREAT
Havana Jack's Oceanside Restaurant and Bar offers guests an inviting tiki bar atmosphere right on the Atlantic Ocean, blending Caribbean-inspired cuisine with classic American fare. The menu highlights fresh seafood, tropical cocktails, and island-themed dishes, complemented by live music and entertainment. Diners enjoy a lively, beachfront setting perfect for a relaxed meal or evening out by the water.
3. Cabana Club
EXCLUSIVE POOLSIDE EATS
Cabana Club offers a casual poolside dining experience reserved for members and their guests, with a menu focusing on American standards and bar favorites. Patrons enjoy burgers, sandwiches, salads, and cold drinks while relaxing at the private pool and beach area. The venue is renowned for its laid-back family-friendly atmosphere and beautiful ocean views.
4. El Molcajete
FLAVORFUL MEXICAN CUISINE
El Molcajete brings authentic Mexican and Latin flavors to Key Colony Beach, offering enchiladas, tacos, and creative margaritas in a friendly, colorful setting. The menu is built around fresh ingredients and bold seasonings, with specialties like carne asada and vibrant vegetarian options. Its welcoming vibe and tropical ambiance make it a great spot for a delicious, casual meal.
5. Island Fish Company
WATERFRONT SEAFOOD SPOT
Island Fish Company is a popular waterfront restaurant in Marathon, celebrated for its open-air tiki bar and fresh-caught seafood. Menu highlights include conch fritters, tuna poke bowls, and a wide selection of grilled fish and shellfish, all served with a view of the marina. The laid-back Keys atmosphere and sunset views make it a top destination for casual waterside dining.
6. Sparky's Landing Fish and Cocktails
LIVELY DOCKSIDE GRILL
Sparky's Landing Fish and Cocktails is a lively, open-air dockside restaurant specializing in fresh seafood, craft cocktails, and live entertainment. The menu is known for its creative daily fish specials, hearty appetizers, and laid-back island vibe. Diners can enjoy waterfront views and breezy outdoor seating, perfect for a festive group meal or sunset happy hour.
7. Frank's Grill
ITALIAN COMFORT FOOD
Frank's Grill offers homemade Italian dishes in a cozy, family-friendly setting, focusing on pasta specialties, wood-fired pizzas, and classic seafood preparations. The restaurant is locally loved for its generous portions, welcoming staff, and relaxed atmosphere. Signature plates like veal parmigiana and seafood linguine attract both locals and vacationers seeking authentic Italian cuisine in the Keys.
8. Triton Seafood Restaurant
CONTEMPORARY SEAFOOD DINING
Triton Seafood Restaurant provides an upscale yet approachable environment to enjoy Caribbean-influenced seafood dishes and inventive cocktails. The menu features daily-caught fish, shrimp, and lobster alongside creative specials with bold flavors. Its contemporary décor, attentive service, and waterfront location create a refined but unpretentious dining destination.
9. Angler & Ale at Hawks Cay
UPSCALE MARINA EATERY
Angler & Ale at Hawks Cay Resort marries refined Floridian seafood with a marina-side setting, embracing both fresh catch and comfort favorites. The menu boasts a variety of island-inspired starters, locally sourced fish, and hearty burgers, perfect for families and couples alike. Stylish décor, attentive service, and panoramic water views make it a standout for relaxed, sophisticated dining.
10. Porky's Bayside Restaurant and Marina
RETRO KEYS BBQ & SEAFOOD
Porky's Bayside Restaurant and Marina invites guests to enjoy a retro Florida Keys experience with a menu centered around slow-smoked barbecue, fresh seafood, and classic sides. The open-air, waterfront location features picnic tables and tropical décor, fostering a laid-back atmosphere ideal for families and groups. Menu highlights include pulled pork sandwiches, baby back ribs, and Florida shrimp, all served with scenic marina views.