Middletown IowaRESTAURANTS & PLACES TO EAT
Listed below are some of the best restaurants and places to eat near Middletown, Iowa.
1. All-Star Maid-Rite Diner
CLASSIC HOMESTYLE COMFORT FOOD
All-Star Maid-Rite Diner offers a variety of homestyle dinners, sandwiches, and salads with 16 different meal options to choose from. The restaurant is known for its homemade desserts and boasted chicken dishes that appeal to families looking for traditional American fare. With 75 years of experience, this diner has established itself as a longtime fixture in the Middletown dining scene.
2. Uncle Ronnie's
FAMILY-FRIENDLY LOCAL FAVORITE
Uncle Ronnie's serves delicious food that appeals to every member of the family with some of the best tenderloins in the area. Their menu highlights include exceptional taco salads that have earned a reputation for being some of the finest available locally. The restaurant offers a welcoming atmosphere that makes it a go-to spot for locals seeking quality comfort food.
3. Casey's
PIZZA AND CONVENIENCE
Casey's in Middletown offers outstanding pizza featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and only the freshest toppings. Located at 75 Main St, this establishment combines convenience store practicality with quality food offerings that exceed expectations. Casey's has become a reliable option for locals seeking quick, satisfying meals with consistent quality.
4. Mazzio's Italian Eatery
ITALIAN CUISINE BUFFET
Mazzio's Italian Eatery provides a casual dining experience featuring Italian cuisine with a focus on good value. With 64 years in the business, this establishment offers both menu service and a buffet option for diners seeking variety. The restaurant strikes a balance between affordable pricing and satisfying Italian-American favorites that appeal to a broad audience.
5. The Broadway Bar and Grill
FAMILIAR FOOD AND FACES
The Broadway Bar and Grill has been serving the Middletown community for 17 years with a menu of casual American favorites. This establishment prides itself on personalized service where staff remember regular customers' usual orders, creating a homey atmosphere. The restaurant combines the sociable environment of a bar with quality grill items that satisfy locals looking for reliable dining options.
6. Big Muddy's
HISTORIC DINING ESTABLISHMENT
Big Muddy's stands as a historic culinary landmark with an impressive 127 years of service to the Middletown area. This longstanding establishment has built its reputation on consistency and traditional American fare that resonates with generations of local diners. The restaurant offers a glimpse into the region's culinary heritage while continuing to serve dishes that keep customers returning.
7. La Tavola Italian Restaurant & Pizza
QUAINT ITALIAN DINING
La Tavola Italian Restaurant & Pizza offers an intimate dining experience in a small but charming space that emphasizes quality over quantity. Their menu features excellent Italian cuisine with generous portion sizes that provide good value for diners. The restaurant combines attentive, polite service with authentic Italian flavors for a complete dining experience.
8. Family Buffet
ALL-YOU-CAN-EAT VARIETY
Family Buffet has been serving the Middletown community for 15 years with an expansive all-you-can-eat format designed to satisfy diverse appetites. The restaurant emphasizes variety with multiple food stations featuring American classics and international options under one roof. This buffet-style establishment provides a casual, family-friendly atmosphere where groups can enjoy meals together with something for everyone.
9. The Drake Restaurant
TRADITIONAL AMERICAN DINING
The Drake Restaurant has established itself as a dining institution in Middletown over its 21 years of operation. The restaurant serves traditional American fare in a conventional dining setting that appeals to those seeking familiar comfort foods. While the establishment has faced comments about service speed, its longevity suggests a loyal customer base that appreciates its consistent menu offerings.
10. Peaches
LOCAL DINING SPOT
Peaches offers a hometown dining experience that reflects the small-town charm of Middletown. The restaurant likely features American classics with possible Southern influences suggested by its fruit-inspired name. This establishment contributes to the local dining scene with approachable food in a casual setting that serves as a gathering place for community members.